Whispers

Blame Poor Planning, Not David Moyes

Image for Blame Poor Planning, Not David Moyes

West Ham defender Luizao is understandably frustrated at his lack of first-team chances since moving from Brazil to East London.

And it seems the person who has received the brunt of the criticism is former Hammers gaffer David Moyes, who is accused of “buying ready-made players instead of preparing the younger ones”.

In defence of Moyesie, I doubt very much if Luizao’s transfer from SĂŁo Paulo was anything to do with the Scotsman. The deal itself has the whiff of what I often call a ‘Wellington Paulista’ type punt—roughly translated, a gamble on an unknown Brazilian by David Sullivan.

These types of transfers rarely come off—for West Ham at least—and whilst I can understand the central defender’s frustration, it’s not really Moyes’ fault. I’ve seen Luizao play live on two occasions and if I’m honest, both Kaelan Casey and Michael Forbes looked to be the better players.

Perhaps it was a fish out of water situation, and it can’t be easy to move from another continent just to play reserve football. That said, the arrival of Julen Lopetegui didn’t seem to improve the defender’s luck, so it’s not all Moyes’ fault.

For the record, this one isn’t on Tim Steidten either, who wasn’t at West Ham when the then 20-year-old agreed to join. If anything, Luizao is the victim of a scattergun transfer policy and the lack of a club structure that really had no plan for the poor fella.

One can only hope that this type of deal will be long gone with Mark Noble now overseeing the recruitment of younger players who will serve their apprenticeship in the U21s.

Share this article

Hammers Chat my first game was West Ham 10-0 Bury . . . seriously!
We than went and bought Bury's central defender 😬⚒️ Irons

I started Hammers Chat alongside my partner in crime Geo back in 2014 and brough in to Claret & Hugh by my old mate Hughie to produce videos a couple of years later.

I give West Ham opinions and interviews on Sky Sports News and even did a bit of moonlighting on BBC Football Focus. Former video and content creator for West Ham United back in the days of Upton Park. I was lucky enough to feature in the documentary broadcast on that final wonderful game at the Boleyn when Winston Reid broke Manchester United hearts.

I frequently feature on BBC Radio 5 Live and once ate a biscuit in Tony Gales shed.

Connoisseur of salted caramel doughnuts and I love a Sloppy Giuseppe pizza although I'm slightly suspicious where the name came from.

When I'm not moaning about West Ham I can be found walking a dog that looks like a sheep and tinkering with pinball machines.

More West Ham moaning is done on a daily basis here 👇👇
https://www.youtube.com/@HammersChatForum

X account can be found here: https://x.com/GONZObignose