web analytics

Dean’s back with a red card and dodgy decision

Mike Dean made his return to the game at Burnley yesterday after his dreadful Tomas Soucek decision at Fulham and was once again in the middle of more controversy.

After having Tomas’s red card overturned on appeal following the same decision after showing  Southampton’s James Bednarek red a week earlier,  he was at it again at Turf Moor

This time he dismissed West Brom’s Semi Ajayi after 30 minutes before turning his back on a strong penalty shout in the second half.

Ajayi was shown a straight red after video assistant referee intervention, with the defender adjudged to have denied a goal scoring opportunity when handling the ball on the halfway line.

VAR controversially did not encourage Dean to consult the pitchside monitor in the 53rd minute when Albion skipper Kyle Bartley appeared to control a Conor Townsend header with an outstretched arm inside his own box.

The game’s biggest talking point surrounded the decision not to penalise Baggies defender Bartley and award Burnley a penalty.

“That has got to be a penalty,” said BBC Radio 5 Live summariser Pat Nevin.

Start supporting Claret and Hugh today Claret & Hugh’s team of creators work with passion and pride to bring you the quality of content that keeps you coming back for more. Support for our creators, however big or small, will help us keep your Hammers content fresh, frequent and loyal to the club. £5 per month £10 per month £20 per month £50 per year

“Mike Dean has walked away, he’s not interested – but that is a clear handball to me. Surely they’ve got to have a look at that?”

Former Manchester United striker Dion Dublin was also convinced the Clarets should have been awarded a spot-kick as he watched the game on BBC One’s Final Score.

“I’ve seen the replays a few times,” he added. “You can see it hits Bartley’s right hand below his elbow. It’s a penalty.”

ClaretandHugh says: It’s becoming increasingly hard to take Dean seriously as a referee in this era. His decision making and connection with the VAR team becomes increasingly fragile week by week. In fact this was his first game since 2020 after being taken off the list at his own request and one can only hope that we don’t get him over the rest of the season as controversy simply follows the man around. He and his bosses were probably hoping for a quiet return after the events at St Mary’s and Craven Cottage but the reality is Dean doesn’t do quiet. It will be interesting to see what Dean decides to do as far as his career is concerned at the end of this troubled season.

Click Here for Comments >

About Hugh5outhon1895

Hugh Southon is a lifelong Iron and the founding editor of ClaretandHugh. He is a national newspaper journalist of many years experience and was Bobby Moore's 'ghost' writer during the great man's lifetime. He describes ClaretandHugh as "the Hammers daily newspaper!" Follow on Twitter @hughsouthon

6 comments on “Dean’s back with a red card and dodgy decision

  1. Sack Ne. Bean

  2. Yep I lived in Walthamstow, where at my school the majority were Spurs fans the first football match I ever saw was at White Hart lane. But The Hammers were my Dads team, so they were mine, I always stood in the chicken run.

  3. Everytime he refs now he gives a Red & has some iffy decisions. Also the offsides rule is ridiculous now it off by a hair. I thought Dean was going take some time off, he should be given time off now. I wouldnt demote him bc then that’s harsh on Championship.
    Can think of his name blanking right now but was it the same bloke on VAR as our game & Southamptons they should not be paired together.
    One Pundit said it well that Refs shouldn’t be on VAR, there is definitely biasist & there should be VAR specialists trained to do this & with knowledge & not to get involved when clear not necessary.

  4. Although I definitely don’t agree with the death threats he has received not only Dean but almost all of the referees in the PL either need support and retraining or retiring, they have been useless for at least a couple of decades, frequently favouring the big clubs as evidenced at the end of each season in dodgy decisions that benefitted the top clubs.

  5. This was his 8th game in 2021, not his first since 2020

Comments are closed.