How CandH FB member rated the Irons

We have a guest ratings expert on board tonight – ClaretandHugh FB Group member Sean Oakley – welcome aboard mate …you can take the flak for a change ūüôā

PayetnewimageRandolph:¬†Couldn’t do anything about first goal and didn’t have much to do after that 7

Antonio: Stepped in at right back and didn’t stop running…¬†as unlucky not to find the net 8
Collins:¬†Absolute rock at the back… controls the defence and didn’t put a foot wrong all game 8
Ogbonna:¬†Didn’t seem to do much from where I was sitting (maybe because Ginge had such a good game though) 6
Cresswell: Based purely on the chances and link up play created with Payet and Lanzini towards the end 7
Kouyate:¬†Unlucky not to score being a toe offside… even more unlucky to have seen a straight red¬†7
Noble: Absolute boss! Puts in tackles all over the field and wears his heart on his sleeve 8
Obiang:¬†Not his best game for us… struggled to find that control that we know he has 6
Moses:¬†Fantastic finish for his goal but for me isn’t as good as Antonio in this position 7
Payet: Unbelievable!! Would have been a 10 but for attempted cheeky flick outside his own area which led to their goal 9
Emenike: Missing in the first half but showed his speed power and natural finishing ability in the second half with two great goals… unlucky not to get his hat-trick 8

Lanzini 7, Song 7, Oxford 6


About Hugh5outhon1895

Hugh Southon is a lifelong Iron and the founding editor of ClaretandHugh. He is a national newspaper journalist of many years experience and was Bobby Moore's 'ghost' writer during the great man's lifetime. He describes ClaretandHugh as "the Hammers daily newspaper!" Follow on Twitter @hughsouthon

7 comments on “How CandH FB member rated the Irons

  1. Neither Ogbonna or Obiang deserved a 6,
    And as for Collins never put a foot wrong all game he must have had a nap at times,Ginge made 2 mistakes that could have given away goals but we know he does that at times,
    Emenike looks the part his one on one against the keeper was class AC could not have done that he gives us something only Sakho gives us,
    We could have found another bargain and I have a feeling Moses won’t want to go back to Chelski but his price could be a problem

  2. Agreed Bubs, you cannot say Collins never put a foot wrong when he clearly passed straight to the Blackburn player which then formed an attack,

  3. Would love to score a game for you Hugh but not sure Sunderland would be the best game for me because of my strong feelings and how important personally I feel that we need to destroy the mundane boring football that will be played against us,
    Yes I have strong feelings about football but I love Ginge and part of his 100% effort game at times is he makes mistakes,
    In the past I have complained about the keeper getting poor scores when he has kept a clean sheet and done nothing wrong when that’s his job,
    Obiang did what was required of him but he deserved at least a 7
    Ogbonna played as well as all the other defenders sorry another 7
    That’s what makes this site so great Hugh you give us a voice but I would love to score a game and then my neck would be on the line no problem

  4. Sean Oakley I ment no offence and am sure none was taken on all your other scores and comments I agree,but my voice counts for nothing it’s just great to debate in this boring world,

  5. Ok tell me which game you want Bubs?

  6. The FA cup final would be great,
    You pick and contact me Hugh,
    Can do Sunderland if you want I am sure I can control my enthusiasm for the power of the

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *