Whispers

“Insulting Offer” Liverpool’s Ridiculous Valuation of West Ham Midfielder

Image for “Insulting Offer” Liverpool’s Ridiculous Valuation of West Ham Midfielder

Liverpool have been in talks with the representatives of West Ham midfielder Mateus Fernandes over a potential summer move to Anfield.

As Claret & Hugh covered last night, Arne Slot’s side — who’ve had a proper shocker of a season after winning the title — are desperate to sort out their underperforming midfield. Fernandes has stood out for West Ham even in a struggling team since arriving from Southampton, and now Liverpool fancy him.

Jorge Mendes is involved, so let’s be honest, players getting touted around isn’t exactly a shock. But the bit that’s properly wound me up is this rumoured £55 million fee. Are they having a laugh?

Why £55m for Mateus Fernandes is an insult to West Ham

We shelled out nearly £40m to bring the Portuguese midfielder in from Southampton, and there’s a sell-on clause in there too.

At £55m we wouldn’t be seeing much profit at all after everyone takes their cut.

The reality is Liverpool seem to think they can just rock up and nick arguably our best player on the cheap while we’re fighting our own battles this season. It’s beyond ridiculous.

Nuno Espirito Santo celebrates Fernandes goal

Fernandes has thrived at West Ham as is now wanted on the cheap by Liverpool

The comparison that makes no sense

Look at Adam Wharton at Crystal Palace.

He’s been valued at over £80m by some, and he’s an elite passer, fair enough, but he still hasn’t scored a single Premier League goal in nearly three years.

Fernandes brings the full package — goals, assists, work rate, the lot — and he’s shown it week in, week out even when West Ham haven’t been at it.

£55m is a crazy low figure for what he’s done and what he could still become.

Player Club Apps (Starts) Minutes Goals Assists Shots
Mateus Fernandes West Ham 29 (28) ~2,400 3 3 22
Adam Wharton Crystal Palace 27 (26) ~2,170 0 5 26

West Ham must not get this wrong

If Liverpool want him, they’re going to have to cough up proper money, not try and pull a fast one. That said, I’m fast coming to the conclusion that the hammers are set to lose Fernandes even if we do dodge relegation.

The club are skint, Jorge Mendes is already offering him around and let’s face it, the 21 year old is so good that West Ham under the current ownership can’t match his talent or ambition. But . . . it’s imperative any transfer fee reflects that fact.

Share this article

Kris Gonzo (commonly known to the West Ham community as Gonzo) is the co-founder of Hammers Chat (established 2014) and the lead video content creator and columnist for Claret and Hugh.

With over a decade of professional sports media experience, he is a frequent West Ham United analyst and contributor for Sky Sports News, BBC Football Focus, and BBC Radio 5 Live. He previously served as an official video and content creator for West Ham United FC during the club's tenure at Upton Park and featured in the official documentary commemorating the historic final game at the Boleyn Ground.

A lifelong Hammer since the legendary 10-0 victory over Bury, when he isn't providing daily match analysis on the Hammers Chat YouTube Channel or broadcasting on X (@GONZObignose), he can be found walking his dog and restoring classic pinball machines.

5 comments

  • Dagenham Dave says:

    Liverpool know we’re the worst negotiaters of a player in Europe, so like Spurs mugged us off with Kudus, Liverpool see us as easy pickings. Compare that to Forest who told Spurs to do one when they wanted Gibbs White

  • Willsy says:

    Why are Liverpool holding talks with his agents when he’s our player, thought that wasn’t allowed. If they do want him £104 million, debt wiped out, simple.

  • Macephtopheles says:

    On one hand, £55m is a ridiculous figure. But on the other, I’m pretty sure that fee is specifically in mind with us potentially being in the Championship next year.

    You can argue that a player doesn’t become less of a player so the fee should remain the same but it just doesn’t work like that.

    If we’re to go down, then a £55/60m fee for Fernandes is likely going to be a good fee. It’s just the reality of not being able to argue from a position of strength. Look at Juve when they were demoted to Serie B and a whole bunch of players were sold at as much as over half their market value. Just how it is, really.

  • Hammeroo says:

    Man United were reportedly after Mateus Fernandes only a couple weeks ago. So if Liverpool think they can have a free run then they are dreaming. But the sheer arrogance of the Big Six clubs is beyond belief with their attitude. I just wish we could tell them to p*ss off!

Comments are closed.