Moyes in a quandry

Tomas Soucek proved David Moyes' decision to give him a new contract at West Ham right

Moyes in a quandry

West Ham United‘s sluggish start to 2024 has intensified calls for a tactical shift, with supporters yearning for a more vibrant and attacking brand of play. This has placed manager David Moyes in a quandary, with some pundits suggesting the potential dropping of key players Tomas Soucek and Vladimir Coufal.
Despite West Ham’s relatively consistent performance under Moyes’ pragmatic approach, fans are expressing dissatisfaction with the team’s recent lethargic displays. Citing matches against Sheffield United, Brighton, Bristol City, and Bournemouth, they’re demanding a shift towards more dynamic and attacking football.
While both Soucek and Coufal are widely recognised for their work ethic and past contributions, their limitations on the ball are under scrutiny. Some argue that their discomfort in possession and perceived slowness in transition impede West Ham’s attacking flow.

Moyes in a quandry

It has to be said that Moyes might need to prioritize ambition over sentimentality. While acknowledging Soucek and Coufal’s dedication, their limitations might hinder the team’s pursuit of a top-six finish, Moyes’ stated goal. Dropping them, though a potentially unpopular decision, is presented as a calculated risk necessary to unlock the team’s attacking potential.
Kalvin Phillips and Ben Johnson are potential immediate replacements for Soucek and Coufal, respectively. But we still need long-term solutions in the summer transfer window, like the promising Cody Drameh (right-back) and hopefully another technically gifted central midfielder.
There are of course inherent risks involved in such a drastic tactical shift. Dropping experienced players could potentially disrupt team chemistry and morale, raising concerns about the impact on overall performance. Ultimately, the decision rests with Moyes, who must carefully weigh the potential benefits against the perceived risks.
The Irons stand at a crucial crossroads. Embracing a bolder, more attacking style could ignite fan enthusiasm and potentially lead to greater attacking success.
 However, it comes with the possibility of unintended consequences and requires careful planning and execution. As the season unfolds, Moyes’ tactical choices will reveal his vision for the club’s future and whether he is willing to take the gamble for a more thrilling brand of football
I fear that his built in pragmatism will still continue to hold sway, and it will be the same old drab fare we have now come to expect.

Share this article

Hugh Southon is a lifelong Iron and the founding editor of ClaretandHugh. He is a national newspaper journalist of many years experience and was Bobby Moore's 'ghost' writer during the great man's lifetime. He describes ClaretandHugh as "the Hammers daily newspaper!"

Follow on Twitter @hughsouthon


  • West Aussie Hammer 1 says:

    This won’t happen, Moyes only knows one way to play and that is everyone in the defensive 6 yard box

  • Mr Buddy Lurve says:

    During the Bristol City game, Moyes could be heard willing the team to move forward. If they aren’t doing that, it’s either because a) they don’t have the vision, awareness and skill to execute his wishes, or b) what he says to them isn’t being understood, or c) what he says on match day conflicts with what he says on the training pitch, leading to hesitation (because the mindset he cultivates is one of fear, leading them to a ‘safety first or I’ll get told off’ mentality).

    If the problem is “a”, then we need to swap players out with different ones. It’s Moyes’s job to request players with different attributes, be they new signings or ideally from our academy.

    If the problem is “b”, then they’re either not very bright, or there is an articulation problem. He has a course Scottish accent that most Brits would find it difficult to understand, let alone foreign players…!

    If the problem is “c”, which I suspect it is, then that’s his job as a manager to provide clarity of intention and clear instructions for execution.

    I believe the problem is a mix of them all.

  • jaybs says:

    Moyes in a quandary, LOL! Is he ever any different! Looking at him on the touch line, is enough to put players off! No wonder, another player we wanted seems to have chosen Brighton. WE ARE A JOKE!

Comments are closed.