Potter’s decision on West Ham striker has been proved correct

The ongoing saga of West Ham’s failure to sign a decent front man transcends several coaches and technical directors. With the benefit of 20:20 hindsight, it would seem that even amidst all of his nonsensical tactics and failed strategies, former boss Graham Potter did make one correct call.

Back in February, Potter managed to secure Evan Ferguson on loan in a bid to strengthen a squad that was struggling for firepower up front. The Republic of Ireland striker arrived with promise, but his impact was minimal, clocking just 137 minutes of game time without registering a goal or assist. Critics blamed Potter for not selecting him: It appears that other managers, since that ill-fated loan spell, have agreed with the former Hammers head coach in his assessment of Ferguson.

Allowing Ferguson to languish on the bench was criticised at the time

In July 2025, Ferguson joined Roma on a season-long loan, with an option to buy. The move was seen as a strategic step to gain experience in a new league and reignite his form.

However, things didn’t go as planned. Despite featuring regularly, Ferguson has struggled to adapt to Roma’s tactical setup and Serie A’s defensive rigour. Nine games in, he remains goalless, with one assist and his confidence appears to have waned. Roma’s attacking woes have only amplified scrutiny, and Ferguson’s lack of impact has led to questions about his role in the squad.

As a consequence reports today suggest that Ferguson’s loan spell at AS Roma is being renegotiated, with Brighton & Hove Albion preparing to recall the striker.

Ferguson’s journey began with promise. Born in Bettystown, Ireland, he joined Brighton’s academy in 2021 after impressing at Bohemians. By 2022, he had broken into the first team and quickly made headlines with his mature performances and clinical finishing. His breakout season saw him net six goals in the Premier League, earning praise from pundits and a call-up to the Republic of Ireland senior squad.

Whether Ferguson reclaims his spot at Brighton or seeks another loan, his development will be closely watched. The early recall from Roma may be a setback, but it’s also potentially an opportunity and a chance to reset, refocus, and prove that his early promise was no fluke.

As for West Ham, Nuno Espírito Santo is on the hunt for a new striker in the January transfer window with Joshua Zirkzee at Manchester United a key target.  However, C&H can safely confirm that Ferguson won’t be returning to the London stadium to don a claret and blue shirt anytime soon.