O’Brien: Gives us nothing – part of our history 4
Collins: Sturdy performance before hobbling off. Battled to stay on. No complaints 6
Reid: Was made to look a mug by Sterling on occasions but battled 5
Cresswell: Not the high quality display we’re used to. Caught out a couple of times 6
Song: Nothing like as mobile in possession as when he arrived, struggled 5
Downing: Played out of position – never a danger 5
Amalfitano: Sparky at times – looked dangerous before being inexplicably subbed 6
Valencia: Had he got Chelsea on his mind? Annonymous 5
Nolan: Tip of the diamond – Nolan? Oh please! Nothing to offer 4
Carroll: Nothing like the high energy player we’ve seen of late 5
Subs: Noble 5, Demel 5 Cole 4