Byram: Defended well – looks very composed – and got forward well 7
Collins: What you see is what you get including one huge error and got out of gaol by Oggy when all looked lost 6
Ogbonna Never put a foot wrong. Have loved this guy from Day One 8
Cresswell: Steady enough but not one of his really great days 6
Noble Great range of passing and fabulous goal – excellent 8,
Obiang Always progressive, powerful and energetic – better bet than Song when Kouyate’s back 7
Antonio: Ineffective on an afternoon when his pace and strength could have been key 5
Payet: The dazzling runs have disappeared for now but big signs he’s on his way back. Good goal and some great passes 8
Valencia Poor first touch and showing too much of the ball to defenders was a problem 5
Subs used: Moses (7), Carroll (6), Emenike (5).