Fabianski: Not entirely to blame but involved in huge mix up for first goal, dropped ball from corner for second 4 for one or two decent saves
Coufal; Another good performance on one of the most difficult afternoons since he joined the club 7
Dawson: Two yellows for two horrible fouls – dreadful afternoon 2
Ogbonna: Unsurprisingly rusty on his first appearance back but grew into it 5
Johnson: Made one amazing goal line clearance and some good tackles but responsible largely for Newcastle’s winner, not always on the money with crosses but a reasonable afternoon beyond that important error 5
Noble: Worked hard across the middle with passes generally finding their men. No complaints 6+
Soucek: Neat and tidy throughout and always finding his man with often one touch passes 7
Fornals: Nothing to complain about in this display, hard working and determined as he tried to make things happen 5=
Lingard: Worked hard throughout in what looked a lost cause for too long before he smashed home a cracking penalty. Injured towards the end and limped off 6
Bowen: Struggled like most of the offensive players despite the usual wholehearted effort 5
Subs
Benrahma: Very similar to previous sub appearances. Energetic but couldn’t provide that finishing touch 5
Lanzini: Late arrival No rating
Fredericks: Late arrival No rating