This Championship season has thrown up some riveting talking points as West Ham’s ‘remainers’ – the players who didn’t want out or get sold in the summer – come to terms with the fast paced, no quarter given football of the second division.
The Irons started the season back in August – looking shellshocked and with a definite relegation hangover – with a dodgy draw away at Turf Moor and then a loss against London neighbours Charlton Athletic as they looked anything but solid in defence.
Familiar frailties raised their head again and the Kilman-Mavropanos pairing was deemed deeply suspect.
So what has changed? Dinos has gone back to being his usual self – solid, sturdy – still reminiscent of a young Rio Ferdinand with a maddening momentary lapse of concentration present in just about every game: The surprise package seems to be Maximilan Kilman.
Many – Claret and Hugh included – were calling for Kilman’s place to go instead to Airidas Golambeckis after the Millwall debacle. However, it is undeniable that something seems to have shifted.
Whether it is confidence, coaching, practise, or simply that attacking opponents are less brutal in this division – but Kilman the gentle giant seems to have found a level where he can perform adequately in defence, and as a plus for Nuno’s side, now actually start to bring the ball out from the back line.

After a trademark dodgy start to the season, Maximilian Kilman does seem to have turned it round
Not a complete metamorphosis, granted, but perhaps enough to save West Ham diving headlong into the winter market for another emergency centre back in a carbon-copyAxel Disasi loan move which they undertook 12 months ago for the exact same reason – to shore up their dreadfully leaky Todibo – Mavropanos – Kilman back line.
Of course, Kilman still looks anything other than the £40 million defensive monolith he was supposed to be (a price tag which hangs very heavily around his neck) and there’ll be a difficult decision to take should the Hammers make it back to the top tier where he’s been found out once before.
But for now, Kilman does seem to have turned it round. Good for him. We’ve given him so much criticism it seems only fair to apply the adage of ‘credit where it’s due’.
Kilman has found his level. It is as simple as that. Yes, his confidence may be higher but also the level of striker is way below that of the PL. He is not, and never will be, a £40m defender. He gets beaten in the air way too easily for one
People hoping that Kilman will improve are deluding themselves. I don’t know what “Loopy” saw that made us pay forty million but since the day he arrived he’s been mediocre at best. He was a total waste of money!
Martin Have a close look at the majority of the goals we have conceded then come back with a reasesment of Kilman nothings changed from last season mate
Kilman’s still very ordinary even at this level. He’s made mistakes in matches and he almost gifted Swansea an equaliser via a typically awful clearing header in our last match.
He’s easily the worst signing in the club’s history despite all the competition we have there. £40m on a centre-back is a serious amount of money for any club.
I don’t want him anywhere near the team. If we do go up, he has to go. He’s simply nowhere near good enough for Premier League football.
The answer is as you mentioned ‘attacking opponents are less brutal in this division’. Kilman is still making mistakes only they aren’t being punished. He made a huge error on Saturday leading to that glorious chance the Swans centre back smashed wide. Assuming West Ham get promoted I’d keep him as he’s likely to be content at being 4th choice centre back which is what he should be in the prem.
West Ham is a football club, not a hospice for broken footballers. Nobody turns up on game day to see how Kilman’s recovery is going. Credit where it is due, yes and that goes to the fact that the Championship, or second division as you still insist on calling it, is a lot easier than the Premier League (First Division), and maybe you are right that the current level is the pinnacle for Max Kilman (and a few others). I cannot imagine why he would look more comfortable against Lincoln than Liverpool.
Aside from his goals it’s Mavrapanos thats been providing the calamitous moments. Those goals have somewhat diverted attention to the fact that he can’t play simple passes with them being over hit or entirely inaccurate. He also regularly gets stranded and ends up in a foot race with a striker due to poor positioning and slow thinking.
Kilman has been as steady as s rock. His confidence is really starting to show and has started getting quite physical with strikers and dominating. The pair of them are both entirely capable of forming a decent partnership by using this season as a test bed to try and work out better communication skills and understanding of each others responsibilities.
I think defensively our best duo is Kilman and Golembeckis though Mav gives us goal threat which is more important in our bid to go up.
Against PL sides they press a lot more from the front and Mav /Kilman are a liability so I want Golembeckis to get more game time, he is a better bet if we have to close games out than the other options Nuno has tried.
I did think the Kilman, Golambeckis pairing worked very well in the match against Soton. Seemed to have a good understanding.
Have to be honest, I don’t know which is the best CB pairing but think Golambeckis will be a great CB in the future and would really like him to be given his chances this season to establish himself.
Dinos is great because he plays his heart out for the team, Same last season even before Disasi arrived and he was receiving plenty of criticism, but he kept on playing his heart out. Now he is part of any drive and passion on a pitch so I would always opt for Dinos, except when he needs a break.
It’s the 3rd season of Kilman’s 7 year contract. At the end of this season his price needs to be close to £23million to avoid making a loss. If we get promotion he’ll have to go at a loss, he’s just not PL standard.
I think Kilman is getting some real therapy in this division, maybe his West Ham career will benefit and hopefully if we go straight up he’ll get stronger.