Just over one year ago, West Ham’s Finlay Herrick was stepping out on loan for Boreham Wood in the National League – the fifth tier of English football. A far cry from London Stadium yesterday as he replaced Mads Hermansen in goal and made his Championship debut, apparently hearing about his impending start just on the morning of the game.
And despite the first half concession from the corner, Herrick did a pretty fair job with excellent double saves later in the game and some assured glove work catching the ball – which had seemed like a lost art at times in the last couple of years.

Herrick after his unforgettable FA Cup penalty shootout debut last year
This was a massive gamble by Scott Parker which could have backfired dreadfully. With no Areola, the temptation must have been to revert to Hermansen yet the Hammers’ head coach stuck with his instinct. After the first half goal concession, Parker must have wondered – briefly – whether he’d made a huge howler.
Has Herrick done enough to keep his place? It seems Parker is dead set on replacing Hermansen so until Alphonse Areola is ‘fit and ready’ then Herrick should be prepared for more pitch time. He certainly has the ambition:
“I hope this is the start. I hope I’ve done myself justice and proved to the fans that I don’t just want to be third choice, I want to be playing, I want to get back to the Premier League and be part of that”. (whu/youtube)
Describing the competition amongst the trio of goal keepers, Herrick was quick to praise Hermansen for the encouragement and help he’s received recently, describing the three keepers as a team more than individuals fighting amongst themselves for the sole starting spot:
“There’s one goal keeper shirt and there’s three of us – but we’re like a band of brothers and we always stick together, me Mads and Fonz- no matter what. “
Difficult to believe Herrick is still only 20 – he seems to have been around West Ham’s fringes for ever- but he joined the academy at six years old and looks to have the talent to go all the way. From yesterday’s solid start, he didn’t let his manager or his team mates down and should feel rightly pretty proud of himself.
The question for Scott Parker is whether he continues between the sticks at Fratton Park on Tuesday night.
Custom House, I think you are being a bit generous to Herrick in respect of the goal but for him to keep his head together after that and have a good game was impressive.
As for the rest I totally agree. Alvarez was ‘man of the match’ and 99 times out of a hundred we win that game comfortably.
So if a player doesn’t play in a game it means the Manager is dead set to replace them? That means there must be an awful lot of players around the country that Managers are dead set to get rid of 🤣.
Parker rested him which is probably a good thing for Hermansen, but doesn’t mean he is looking to get rid. Let’s not sensationalise a few team changes.
1-1 at home to the worst team in the championship for many years is nothing to be proud of. So far Parker has made a lot of noise and delivered nothing. It’s early days, but the initial signs aren’t encouraging. There is still something fundamentally wrong at the club since a lot of these players weren’t at the club in Moyes final season of decline or when Lopi took over. We were right to sack to Nuno, but the jury is still out as to whether Parker was the right replacement.
I’ve never been to Gratton Park.
I was at the game yesterday & not a million miles away from the goal, it looked to me like young Finn asked Piroe to leave it as he was coming for it but Piroe still glanced it which caused the goal. Not a GK error in my book. I think the lad did well overall & deserves the shirt for the pompey game. Álvarez was good aswell. On another day that would have been a relatively comfortable 3-1 win.