Whispers

Southampton 1 West Ham 4 Player Ratings: Nuno’s Young Guns Deliver

Image for Southampton 1 West Ham 4 Player Ratings: Nuno’s Young Guns Deliver

By Kris Gonzo | Senior West Ham Columnist (Follow on X)

Nuno Espírito Santo took a risk tonight by selecting such a young and inexperienced West Ham team while under considerable pressure. It paid off. The Hammers recovered from a shaky start and going behind to produce an emphatic 4-1 win, with several youngsters giving the manager genuine selection dilemmas ahead of Watford. Nuno will remain under pressure if things go badly at the weekend, but playing the kids and getting a performance like this has certainly helped his cause.

West Ham Player Ratings

Finn Herrick: 5

Couldn’t do anything about Southampton’s opening goal and, for all the Saints’ early attacking, didn’t have too much to do in the first half. Produced one impressive punch. Had a crazy moment on 56 minutes when he ran almost 40 yards from goal and tried to chest the ball under control. Completely unnecessary. Made a comfortable save on 73 minutes before spilling Edozi’s shot late on, with Kilman clearing the danger.

Joël Veltman: 8

Assured and impressive from the start and at times looked a class apart. Reads the game so well and looks like he’ll be a real asset. Outmanoeuvred his marker following Golambeckis’ long ball for West Ham’s third before advancing into the box and cutting back perfectly for Castellanos to score.

Max Kilman: 6

His clearance eventually led to Southampton’s opening goal and he sometimes struggled with their pressing game, hurriedly clearing the ball on a couple of occasions. Headed just wide from Mukasa’s inswinging corner and made a robust, important challenge on 39 minutes to thwart a Saints attack. Cleared the danger after Herrick’s late spill.

Airidas Golambeckis: 6

Good block on former Hammer Divin Mubama and grew in confidence as the game went on. At one point strode forward from defence, overlapped Jarrod Bowen and ended up on the right wing, where his cross was just overhit. Excellent intention and he’ll have learned a lot from the experience. His long ball down the line started the move for West Ham’s third.

Ezra Mayers: 6

Some of his passing lacked accuracy and you could tell at times that he was a central defender playing at left-back. However, he was defensively very good and made an important clearance from Scienza’s pull-back after 18 minutes.

Mohamadou Kanté: 6

Sometimes sloppy in possession but made a couple of important tackles. Probably could have done better as Sienza ran through for Southampton’s opening goal. Definite signs of a midfield partnership developing with Lewis Orford.

Lewis Orford: 8

Continued his improvement with some excellent passing. His reading of the game and willingness to demand the ball from his teammates is impressive given his age. Curled in an excellent corner for Ajala’s first goal and was heavily involved in some of West Ham’s best football. Played his part in the fourth, taking Mukasa’s pass before feeding Bowen.

Divin Mukasa: 8

His energy was evident throughout and he was involved in the excellent move which created the corner for West Ham’s equaliser. Another of the youngsters who did enough to give Nuno a genuine selection headache ahead of Watford. Strode forward with real purpose to start the move which ended with Bowen making it 4-1. Replaced by Casey with seconds remaining.

Keiber Lamadrid: 5

Had a shot from distance which went well wide, although the build-up between him and Veltman was good. You could immediately see the extra quality when Bowen replaced him, but Lamadrid was one of several young players who showed really good energy.

Josh Ajala: 9

Can’t really do much more, can you? Scored West Ham’s equaliser after 40 minutes, heading Orford’s excellent corner in at the far post following a really good team move. Made it 2-1 after 52 minutes, reacting to the rebound from goalkeeper Stevens and finishing expertly into the far corner. Unlucky to be hooked having scored twice, but he’s certainly given Nuno something to think about.

Josh Ajala celebrates after scoring twice for West Ham against Southampton.

Ajala is congratulated by his West Ham teammates

Joel Piroe: 7

Continued where he left off against Charlton by initially showing a lack of physicality in his duels with the Southampton defenders. Improved considerably as the game went on. Forced Stevens into two saves around the 20-minute mark and was unlucky not to win a penalty just before half-time following a good solo dribble.

Produced a sumptuous pass for Ajala’s second, dropping deep before threading a wonderful ball through the Southampton defence. I was disappointed to see him withdrawn because he’d become increasingly influential.

Substitutes

Jarrod Bowen: 7

Immediately brought extra quality. Forced Stevens into a smart save after dropping his shoulder and going onto his weaker foot. Made it 4-1 with probably the most Jarrod Bowen-like goal you’re ever likely to see, cutting inside two Saints defenders onto his left foot before finishing low into the far corner.

Manor Solomon: 6

Magnificent run shortly after coming on saw him slalom past several Southampton players and almost create a goalscoring chance for Bowen. Had a shot from distance.

Taty Castellanos: 7

Forced a corner as West Ham really turned on their attacking game in search of a third. Got his goal after 74 minutes, tapping home from close range following excellent work from Veltman.

Arne Engels: 6

Almost immediately had an impact after replacing Kanté, setting up Bowen for a speculative effort.

Share this article

Kris Gonzo (commonly known to the West Ham community as Gonzo) is the co-founder of Hammers Chat (established 2014) and the lead video content creator and columnist for Claret and Hugh.

With over a decade of professional sports media experience, he is a frequent West Ham United analyst and contributor for Sky Sports News, BBC Football Focus, and BBC Radio 5 Live. He previously served as an official video and content creator for West Ham United FC during the club's tenure at Upton Park and featured in the official documentary commemorating the historic final game at the Boleyn Ground.

A lifelong Hammer since the legendary 10-0 victory over Bury, when he isn't providing daily match analysis on the Hammers Chat YouTube Channel or broadcasting on X (@GONZObignose), he can be found walking his dog and restoring classic pinball machines.

8 comments

  • I'm not the answer to our right back problems says:

    Well, it’s 10.34pm, and I’m just reading all the negative posts about tonight’s team selection from the earlier post once the team lineup was announced. And watching us complete a very well fought match using all the youngsters that were allegedly thrown under the bus tonight by Nuno! you should all have a little more faith and get off his back, is it all Nuno’s fault that most of the Prima donna elite players that got us relegated last season didn’t want to stand up, be counted and get us back where we belong.
    Well done lads 👏 and long may we play like we did tonight.
    COYI ⚒️⚒️⚒️⚒️

  • Prezza says:

    Stevens is their centre half, Peretz is the goalkeeper ! 🤔🤓

  • Oliver says:

    Ajala must be given a chance in league. Mukasa also looks good

  • Peter whu says:

    Thought Kilman had a good game, coming out and battling for the ball – nice to see.

    Lovely attitude from all the starters on the pitch, controlled display of quick passing football.
    Sweet.

    Well done Ajala.

  • Ken Brickell says:

    Like I said previously, attack is the best form of defence. QED

  • Saul says:

    Thought Golambeckis was excellent, looked pretty fearless and not out of his depth at all.

  • Matt says:

    Time to start trusting the academy players more! I’ve seen lots of quality from a few of them, not just the players that played tonight. Earthy could’ve been established and firing by now if properly integrated. We’re lacking defensive midfielders but we’ve sold Potts, who could easily have been a success for us. Battrum and Landers need a shot soon and definitely want to see more of Ajala, Golambeckis and Orford. Let’s stop wasting our young talent. One thing I will say though, we can’t be applauding them being taken off like with Scarles, not good for their confidence and development. Have to accept they will make mistakes but will learn. The mistakes Mavropanos and Killman make are schoolboy, they’re supposed to be established pros!

  • ricardo says:

    After a start lead by the young ones, today it was finally back to winning, and in the end also a much better overall team performance. Interesting contributions -among several other players who did very well today- by Mukasa and Veltman.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *