News

Report: West Ham facing transfer power struggle

|

West Ham supporter Guardian journalist Jacob Steinberg has spilt the beans on the West Ham power struggle happening this summer.

Steinberg writes in the Guardian: “The recruitment strategy at West Ham remains anything but smooth, even with Tim Steidten brought in as the technical director earlier this month. A scattergun process has slowed things down and the German’s appointment, far from ushering in a new era of collaboration, has confused matters.

The problem is that Steidten can be forgiven for wondering why he was hired. One of his picks is Monaco’s Youssouf Fofana, a 24-year-old France international, but Moyes is unsure. Fofana is likely to move elsewhere and Steidten, formerly of Bayer Leverkusen, is said to be frustrated. Some wonder whether he will last. Others suggest that Moyes, who has lost Mark Warburton and Paul Nevin from his backroom staff this summer, will go if West Ham start badly.

These are uncertain times. Moyes has worked closely with Rob Newman, who was appointed as head of recruitment two years ago, but West Ham felt a change was necessary. They were unhappy with their transfer business under Moyes and Newman, whose position is under threat, while considering that Noble needs more support as in his role as sporting director.

Yet the complication caused by hiring Steidten when the transfer window was open is best encapsulated by West Ham losing out to Newcastle in the race to sign Harvey Barnes from Leicester. West Ham had been working on the deal since April, but a reset after Steidten joined meant the opportunity to purchase a winger who would have been an upgrade on Moyes’s options on the left flank disappeared.

So much for getting business done quickly. West Ham did well to get £105m for Rice, but losing their captain and best player is a blow and so far the response has been too reactive. Lodging bids for a variety of players all at once is not indicative of a clear strategy.

Moves for Ajax’s Edson Álvarez and Fulham’s João Palhinha hit brick walls, and a mooted loan of Juventus’s Denis Zakaria has not progressed. As it stands, Moyes is going into the season with Conor Coventry, Flynn Downes, Tomas Soucek and Lucas Paquetá to choose from in midfield.

Of course much can change before West Ham visit Bournemouth in their season opener on 12 August. They are haggling with Southampton over Ward-Prowse, whose set-piece prowess would be invaluable in a Moyes side, and could send Downes to St Mary’s. There is room for negotiation with Chelsea over Gallagher and £45m could convince Manchester United to sell McTominay.

Inevitably there will be those who see McTominay, Gallagher and Ward-Prowse as overpriced, unoriginal targets and question why West Ham are not looking for value in European leagues. Yet Moyes does not need to be imaginative; he needs wins. He will look through West Ham’s squad and see weaknesses.

He wants a centre-back to provide cover for the injury-prone Kurt Zouma – the club had a £20m offer for Harry Maguire turned down – and will need a striker if Antonio and Gianluca Scamacca leave. West Ham, the only Premier League team still to sign anyone in this window, have to react. They are due to buy Carlos Borges from Manchester City for £14m but the winger is 19 and has not played first-team football. It is not enough.

There is still too much dithering. The co-owner, David Sullivan, is in charge of negotiations and is not known for getting deals done quickly. Moyes, notoriously picky over signings, is not on the same page as Steidten.

Put it all together and it hardly seems that West Ham have hit upon a winning formula. Once again they risk not being ready for the start of the season, and this time they cannot count on Rice to paper over the cracks.”

ClaretandHugh says: Jacob Steinberg is not a football to treat anything other than seriously and this is quite a courageous piece given the issues we can all see at the club. His conclusion to the piece says it all when he declares that there is still too much dithering. Not many would argue that David Sullivan is not known for getting deals done quickly and that Moyes is slow in making his mind up on who he wants. Having done so he has often been known to change his mind. It is also becoming obvious – as Steinberg says – that he is not on the same page as Steidten. It remains astonishing that having done a deal the Rice deal for £105 million his replacement is still unknown with Moyes having known this time last year he was on his way,

Share this article

I am Season Ticket Holder in West stand lower at the London Stadium and before that, I used to stand in the Sir Trevor Brooking Lower Row R seat 159 in the Boleyn Ground and in the Eighties I stood on the terraces of the old South Bank. I am a presenter on the West Ham Podcast called MooreThanJustaPodcast.co.uk. A Blogger on WestHamTillIdie.com a member of the West Ham Supporters Advisory Board (SAB), Founder of a Youtube channel called Mr West Ham Football at http://www.youtube.com/MrWestHamFootball,

I am also the associate editor here at Claret and Hugh.

Life Long singer of bubbles! Come on you Irons!

Follow me at @Westhamfootball on twitter

0 comments

  • Clive says:

    Steinberg seems to have a knack of writing disruptive ultra negative hit pieces about West Ham. I’d love to know where he gets it all from.

    • Just happens to be one of the best football writers in the country. Do you have any different information to what he gets which comes from on high

      • Clive says:

        You tell me. I wish I knew but someone obviously enjoys creating disharmony in the fan base because all these constant rumours. It’s like a circus at the moment.

        • Disharmony? Yeah we have only been following the Hammers around for over 60 years and that was our only purpose LOL, Such nonsense, WE have of course only been journos all our life to cause trouble. Dear God

          • geefunkhammer says:

            You know JS is a West Ham fan right? Hardly an agenda to be negative, just hating the farce which is constantly our club. How this summer has been handled is setting new levels of incompetence. Moyes has to go. The players don’t like him, the new tech director doesn’t like him. It’s just holding us back and we’ll end up wasting the Rice cash with his unimaginative transfers.

          • Clive says:

            You miss the point. It’s not the journos to blame if there’s any truth in the rumours. It’s whoever in the club is leaking all this stuff that causes disharmony and disgruntlement among the fan base. They obviously can’t help themselves.

  • johnham1 says:

    Moyes out as soon as possible before we end up in a terrible mess. He demonstrated all that is wrong with him today. 2 DMs on the pitch for the entire game when we were losing. Need to get both Downes and Soucek out of the team before Bournemouth. Do not give him a single say on who we sign as he is the problem nobody else. Back the new DOF very highly respected – we need to trust him to see what he brings and he will certainly bring alot more to the team than Moyes. Rumours are that he is close to walking, what a shame and what an indictment of Moyes.

  • SydneyC says:

    In this case Sullivan and Brady have just as much responsibility. They allowed this situation to develop. I hope this is not some crack-handed attempt by the board to push Moyes out. I don’t think he’s the right manager moving forward but this situation seems to be undermining the Club’s immediate future. Sort it out Sullivan!

  • Auslander says:

    Moyes has to go!

  • Martin61 says:

    A good piece Sean. Despite Johnham1s usual slating of Moyse, this is a combination of factors. Sully’s slow dealings, almost insulting…..actually, simply insulting….lowball first offers continually damage our reputation. Bring back the Cearns/Greenwood/Lyall days of integrity please.

    The apparent and probable clash of culture and beliefs between Moyse and Steidten is not the making of either of them, it was inevitable. I like the idea of Steidten in his role, but his availability and appointment is 6 months too early, given that he is probably there to also seek the replacement for Moyse……but timing of his availability was not in Sullivan’s control, so he probably felt he he had to take the opportunity.

    If Steidten had done his research, he would have realised Sullivan likes managers with Prem experience, not uncovering up and coming modern managers.

    So is Sullivan ‘changing his spots’ with regard future direction? Has Steidten done his homework? As for Moyse, losing much of his leadership team, from Irvine through to Dec with no apparent replacement plan is poor at best, bloody atrocious at worst. His well researched, diligent led process is not looking great at the moment.

    Sullivan and Moyse equally bear responsibility for the transfer and leadership position in the club. Steidten needs to be patient and, whilst on it, Kretinsky needs to think about his role in directing the club.

  • johnham1 says:

    We cannot continue like this – this has to end. Moyes simply will not work with the new DOF. Moyes has left thr club with no choice now but to sack him. He is the problem and was the problem last season.

  • West Ham Fan No 32 says:

    Seems obvious with all the players wanting to leave where the problem lies, Moyes has lost the players, Steidten should be scouting managers not players. Frank at Brentford, DeZerbi, Potter or another that can take us forward and that can build the club.

    • geefunkhammer says:

      None of those names would walk into out car crash club.

      • West Ham Fan No 32 says:

        Think that about sums it up doesn’t it ? We are European Champions, should be riding high but are the lowest of the low in attractiveness, Nevin, Pearce, Warburton gone two at least of whom could no longer work with Moyes, many players trying to get out it seems, clubs offering a pittance compared to what was paid for the players. We need a change of manager and probably a change of owners.

  • SydneyC says:

    I’m not so sure about that geefunk. This may be the optimal time to change managers. You have a good squad with a large transfer kitty, a highly rated DoF, a Europa League place, and a packed stadium every game. If ever you’re going to attract a new manager it’s now, not in Dec when you find the new players you spent the money on are no better than what you have, you’re in a relegation battle, and struggling in Europe.
    But our Board are conservative to a fault, so our next manager will be a Premier League retread.

  • Clive says:

    Martin61 is absolutely right; it’s a combination of factors. Steidten’s appointment may have been premature. While some have been calling for Moyes to be sacked (like a broken record) the ultimate responsibility lies with the owners for the current situation. It seems they chose to keep Moyes but undermined him simultaneously, and that may not be beneficial for anyone involved – not Moyes, Steidten, the owners, or the fans.
    Personally, I understand Moyes’ desire for a British core of players. With Noble and Rice gone, and Cresswell and Antonio possibly leaving, Bowen remains the sole homegrown player in the team. While there are cheaper European options, having a core of British players who understand the fans, the history, and the club’s rivalries is crucial. Recruiting established British players with proven Premier League experience could be exactly what we need at this precise moment.”

Comments are closed.